Can we all stop acting like political Islam means that “Arabs can’t do democracy”?

I mean, really? Talking about the possible dangers of the political rise of the Muslim Brotherhood or the Salafists or the Ennahda Party (particularly when it comes to social freedoms) don’t have to involve saying things like “Are the sceptics who said that Arabs could not handle democracy—and would inevitably elect nasty people who would never surrender power—being proved horribly right?

Just to point out - we rarely look at the Evangelical role in US politics as an argument for a Western inability to successfully implement and maintain a democracy, but Evangelical Christianity’s political and activist role is frequently aimed at detriment to social freedoms like the right to choose or the freedom to plan a family and to have safe sex, or to have the same rights even if you’re gay.* We absolutely need to be talking about what the outcome of Ennahda’s big win in Tunisia and the growing power of the Muslim Brotherhood in Egypt might mean for those populations, but we also need not to get carried away into the land of paternalistic Orientalism and start making broad decisions and evaluations of any culture’s innate ability to form a certain kind of government to our own liking, or make snap decisions for those countries about whether or not their new systems are successfully created.

Important things to remember here when talking about this: not all residents of the Middle East or North Africa are Arab or Muslim; a significant chunk of Egyptians and Tunisians did not vote for political Islam and are exerting pressures on those parties to dilute their politics, make promises about their social policies, and form coalitions with more moderate or secular parties; talking about the failure of a political transition just as it’s officially beginning is hasty and silly; not Western does not equal not successful. 

*If you’re reading this and you’re Evangelical, this is not equivalent to me saying your religion is bad or that you automatically believe these things or act in these ways. I’m talking about the politicized elements seen in and wielded by numerous conservative/Republican candidates and their political influencers.

121 notes

Show

  1. dreamer-in-jeans reblogged this from thepoliticalnotebook
  2. aaa2zee reblogged this from thepoliticalnotebook
  3. alifeinaseriesoflines reblogged this from thepoliticalnotebook
  4. whatgodzillasaidtogod reblogged this from thepoliticalnotebook
  5. mimsicality reblogged this from worldcoup
  6. worldcoup reblogged this from thepoliticalnotebook
  7. pol102 reblogged this from thepoliticalnotebook and added:
    From
  8. vessels reblogged this from afroxander
  9. afroxander reblogged this from thepoliticalnotebook
  10. rasmalaiwin reblogged this from thepoliticalnotebook and added:
    bolding mine
  11. notlesmiserables reblogged this from thepoliticalnotebook and added:
    We actually discussed this in my Comparative Politics course. According to research done by Mark Tessler (as presented...
  12. plasticalibi reblogged this from thepoliticalnotebook
  13. medievalmodern reblogged this from thepoliticalnotebook
  14. chasingcorrelations reblogged this from thepoliticalnotebook
  15. egypttt reblogged this from thepoliticalnotebook
  16. dieseleagle said: religion and the state need to be completely separate in multi cultural society, full stop.
  17. fwdprogress reblogged this from thepoliticalnotebook
  18. theartofdisputatio reblogged this from thepoliticalnotebook
  19. that-flash-bastard reblogged this from thepoliticalnotebook
  20. perihanaaa reblogged this from thepoliticalnotebook

Blog comments powered by Disqus

']); _gaq.push(['_trackPageview']); (function() { var ga = document.createElement('script'); ga.type = 'text/javascript'; ga.async = true; ga.src = ('https:' == document.location.protocol ? 'https://ssl' : 'http://www') + '.google-analytics.com/ga.js'; (document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0] || document.getElementsByTagName('body')[0]).appendChild(ga); })(); // ]]>